NL only Keeper Trade- how'd I do

Did a trade just now.. 11 team NL Only 4x4 roto keeper league (no Runs/Ks)

Gave up:  Allen Craig $10

Got:  Rickie Weeks $20, Madison Bumgarner $22, Rafael Betancourt $20, Matt Adams $10


Liked Craig, but think Weeks, Bum are below value, and I'd now have 3 closers with Betancourt (only 11 NL teams- so should take saves)

Thoughts?

Originally posted by astrosfanatic depends on your cap situation. If you can afford all of those players, then it is definitely a good deal. Craig is a health risk. I am surprised to see Adams at $10 considering he has yet to really accomplish anything. Someone must have been desperate for a prospect. Bummy's greatest asset is his K/9, but that doesn't count in your settings. But he is strong in the other areas as well. And with it being NL-only, i guess that would make him undervalued at 22

Adams was FA pickup (assigned salary of $10)  League has huge inflation due to keepers- but standard $260 cap with 14 H (2 C, 5 OF, 1 U), 9 P

Originally posted by LABLUE Don't usually comment on auction things since I don't play them but 10 for Craig seemed like a great deal over a guy like Weeks for 20 or Bum for 22.

Yea, inflation is huge in our league.. Craig would have gone for 20-25 so there was def. value there..

To compare.. Phillips went for 23, Hill/Espinosa 20 (Hill was kept from 10), Walker 19.. Uggla went for 31 last year to Weeks at 20 is right there with the top 5-6 2B

Bum would go for 25- Kershaw went for 33, Lee 29, Hamels 31 LY

And with 11 teams and 15 teams now, Saves are at a premium- getting 3- Putz, Marmol, Betancourt- puts me in prime position to take Saves and trade for other needs later in the year, even if Marmol loses the job in July

Originally posted by astrosfanatic Marmol might not have the job after Spring Training. didnt they sign that Japanese reliever??

Yep, but doubt he wins it right out of ST, esp. how Marmol finished the season