too much for calvin?

No way do I do that deal. Doesn't matter what else you have. That's WAY too much

Way too much

Calvin Johnson has the most yards in the league as of today. Freeman is out u have stafford. Trent for Calvin is fair. Reggie bush is the new Kevin smith. Do it

I think the only factor you need to consider outside of what has been said is Freeman plays N.O week 15. I am going to use him over Manning,who plays Baltimore, and Manning is better than Stafford this year. Det plays Arizona week 15 who is 3rd against the pass. Freeman had 400+ plus yards with 3 or 4 Td;s against N.O last time out. As for the deal forget all the comments about volume. Starting lineup is all that matters. Bush is almost a non factor now. If the week 15 thing doesn't matter to you it is Trent for Calvin. I don't think Bush is K Smith. That still has me more perplexed that any fantasy situation ever. 7 Td's in 6 1/2 games last year. Well over 100 yards from scrimmage per game. Great week one. S.F. shuts him down and he is in street clothes. I do say Calvin is a better play that Trent form here on out as long as you know Ari and Atlanta (only 11 Td's allowed through the air) are the playoff opponents. Redskins and Broncos are Trent's. $th and 7th against the run. 7 and 5 Td's allowed. OF all the players in the NFL only Peterson is more matchup proof than Calvin. I would do it because if Calvin,which he hasn't been stopped yet, goes off you double up. Playoff time that could bring you the championship.


Edited by hwd23 - 05 Dec 2012 at 6:55pm

95% of the time you see a 3-1 trade it is the far better owner in the league getting the one player back. I know some owners in leagues that wont even look at your offer unless they are getting the one guy or it is a even 2-2 type deal. I will admit I can't remember the last time I took the 3 side of a 3-1 deal. I play in 15 baseball and 15 football leagues per year and never take those deals. I am the one getting the stud to improve my starting lineup while giving up depth.